Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Stan Van Gundy Fired As Head Coach Of The Magic

BlogPoll Ballot Week 8: An Appreciation of Kansas State

MANHATTAN, KS - OCTOBER 1: The Kansas State Wildcats celebrate after recovering a fumble in the first half against the Baylor Bears at Bill Snyder Family Football Stadium on October 1, 2011 in Manhattan, Kansas. The Wildcats won 36-35. (Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images)

As always, this is not a power poll or predictor of future success.  More thoughts after the jump:

Star-divide

No real changes at the top.  Oklahoma was already at three, so their light struggles to put Kansas away early don't affect them.  The winner of LSU and Alabama will play in the national title game, barring an Arkansas upset of the Tigers or Auburn taking down the Tide at the end of the season.  With Marcus Lattimore going down, the SEC East looks like it will provide nothing more than a speed bump come the SEC title game, so again, direct all of your eyes towards November 5th in Tuscaloosa.

Oklahoma State gets a win in Austin and slips ahead of Boise.  Clemson's resume is way better than anything Wisconsin or Stanford can point to, and they should be ranked accordingly.  

The Kansas State Wildcats are 6-0, and after the starting the season with Bill Snyder’s customary sacrifices over Eastern Kentucky and Kent State, they have reeled off four straight victories against respectable to semi-respectable BCS conference foes, including at Miami, Baylor and Mizzou at home and then at Texas Tech this past weekend.  The margin of victory in these last four has all been a touchdown or less, including the escape in Miami, but I’m giving them some love for four straight wins against real teams with real pulses and 85 scholarships.  Good work, K State.

Texas A&M’s blowout win against Baylor shoots them up the rankings and causes to reevaluate their record.  Instead of looking at it as 4-2 with two chokes against Arkansas and Oklahoma State, let’s look at it as 4-2 with two close losses to teams with one combined loss, which came to Alabama.  They could justifiably be moved back, but I’m skewing them to reward the big leads they built up against the Cowboys and Razorbacks instead of punishment for subsequently blowing them.

You try to figure out how to rank Michigan, Michigan State and Notre Dame.  I will rank Penn State when they beat either A) a ranked opponent or B) someone who has defeated a ranked opponent.  (They’ve done neither to this point.)  

~

So what do you guys think?  Any teams that have to be over another team, or any team (save for A&M) that I have ranked way too high or way too low?

Comment 1 comment  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Ranking ND, MSU, and Michigan

Each team won the home game and lost the road game.

ND has the best point differential and the best win/loss distribution, winning handily over the better team and losing by the slimmest of margins over the weaker team.

My sense is that solely on the strength of the games played between the teams, ND is ahead. I’d put MSU in the middle and Michigan at the back.

So the question then becomes, how much of a hit relative to those two teams should ND take for the USF loss?

Who else besides aTm did you move in front of the Irish, and what’s your rationale? Auburn doesn’t pass the smell test for me, but then again, ND’s non-MSU wins are looking worse by the week.

by Mr Wednesday on Oct 17, 2011 5:28 PM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

One Foot Down Community Guidelines

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Img_8102_small
Irish Football and Lost Sleep

Recent FanPosts

Small
Champ Sports condensed/offense-defense cut ups
Small
DaVaris Daniels Cited for Underage Drinking
Small
5 things we need to happen, to have a successful season
C-hurdle_small
Andrew Hendrix Should Start in 2012
Small
College Football Stadium Tour: Michigan Stadium
81375450_small
Off Topic, But Help Me Out
Notre_dame_tradition_is_becoming_dangerously_out_of_control__28funny_cheerleader_picture_29_small
How Steve Bartman is the Cause of SEC Dominance
Nd_stadium_small_quality_small
Athlon Previews the 2012 Fighting Irish
Shamrock_small
Preseason BlogPoll Post-Spring Edition: What Do You Know?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

SHOP THE ONE FOOT DOWN STORE

Gameday Depot University Apparel


Managers

Rocket1_small Eric Murtaugh

Nd_stadium_small_quality_small whiskey OFD

Editors

Jj_small Mouth of the South

Shamrock_small CW

Teo-vs_-service2_small burger23

Nd_national_champs_small Jim Miesle

Febreeze_small 4pointshooter